Driver Error Could Have Caused Soledad Tour Bus Accident
Thursday, May 14th, 2009Preliminary investigations into last month’s tour bus accident near Soledad have linked the cause of the accident to driver error. According to California Highway Patrol investigators, however, it’s not yet clear what caused the error that resulted in the fatal bus accident.
The driver, John Egnew and four French tourists died in the accident when the tour bus crashed into a guardrail on the highway 101 overpass and flipped over. The driver and three of the passengers were ejected and fell on to the road, below the overpass. The bus had been carrying 34 French tourists and their Canadian guide. Several of those injured had been admitted to local hospitals with severe injuries. The bus was on its way to Santa Maria, and had stopped in Monterey and Carmel that day.
California Highway Patrol officers have investigated Egnew’s logbook, and ruled out fatigue as the cause of the accident. Driver fatigue can occur when the driver has logged in more number of hours without a rest break, than stipulated by federal guidelines. A fatigued driver can lose concentration or dose off at the wheel, leading to a bus accident. That doesn’t seem to have happened here.
Alcohol and drugs have also been ruled out as a factor in the crash, because no drugs or alcohol were found in Egnew’s system. The bus was a relatively new one, and had been built in April 2008. Investigators could find no mechanical failures in the bus that could have caused the accident. Mechanical malfunctions of bus components like the wheels, brakes, or tires and other parts can cause a serious crash. A driver operating the bus with alcohol or drugs in the system can also be a possible factor.
The California Highway Patrol team reconstructed the bus accident in an effort to pinpoint the factors that were responsible, and their efforts have ruled out weather conditions as a cause of the crash. It’s not believed that the kinds of winds that would have been necessary to impact the bus, were in the area that day. Egnew’s autopsy has not yet revealed whether he suffered a heart attack or some other medical condition in the moments before the crash. Right now, only this much is clear - the driver failed to make a sharp enough turn to make the right hand curve on the overpass. The result was that the front left corner of the bus crashed into the guardrail. The rear of the vehicle then struck the barrier on the outside of the road. The bus then spun around, and crashed into the inside guardrail, overturned and continued spinning until it came to a stop. Egnew as well as three of the tourists were ejected off the overpass and to the road below. In all, five people were killed in the accident.
So far, Egnew’s speed at the time of the bus accident has not been determined. Egnew as we reported on this blog earlier had been involved in a Las Vegas pedestrian accident in which a 71-year-old woman had suffered serious injuries.
The Reeves Law Group is a law firm with offices throughout California dedicated exclusively to the representation of personal injury victims, including victims of bus accidents. Please visit our website at trlglaw.com. If you desire a free consultation on a personal injury matter, please call us at (800) 644-8000 or email us.
The Reeves Law Group is not acting as legal counsel for any party in the matters discussed in this posting.