Will California’s Cell Phone Ban Prevent Car Accidents?
Monday, June 30th, 2008When a new hand-held cell phone ban goes into effect tomorrow across California, it will signal the start of an experiment of sorts on the ability of the ban to reduce car accidents in the state. Road safety experts and high way traffic administrators will be looking to see if the hand-held ban is going to be as effective as Governor Schwarzenegger hopes it will be, at preventing car accidents in California.
The bill bans the use of hand held cell phones to talk or text message while driving. There’s no way of telling yet how this will affect the way injuries in car accidents are treated. The bill clearly calls for a ban on hand-held devices, and there is a fine of $20 on motorists who violate the ban. No one believes that the threat of the fine in itself will stop car accidents. However, the threat of being liable for damages and fatalities in a car accident caused by the use of a hand held cell phone by the driver who causes the accident could be enough motivation for drivers to switch to hands- free.
As we reported a while back, the potential for manslaughter charges being filed in cases where a driver’s use of hand-held device was seen as a contributing factor in the accident is very real. The real difference between then and now, when it comes to cell phone usage and car accidents, is this: in the past, attorneys had to prove that the cell phone usage was a very real factor that contributed to negligence. Now, the judge will have to inform the jury that using a hand-held cell phone in itself constitutes negligence. The repercussions for personal injury cases are still unclear, but all signs indicate that this is going to be a turning point of sorts both for road safety in the state as well as the issue of compensation for victims of car accidents.
The bill has more than its share of detractors who say that hand-held or hands- free makes no difference at all. Cell phone usage while driving inhibits concentration, slows down reflexes, and is overall just bad news for everybody on the streets, they claim. Banning only hand-held devices is a halfhearted measure, they say, that won’t have any long-term benefits.
Be that as it may, there’s no doubt that there’s something to be said for having both your hands free to make quick decisions while driving. That’s simply not possible when you have a hand holding a cell phone glued to your ear and the other on the wheel. On this very blog, we’ve covered car accidents that have occurred because the driver was too busy doing drug deals, conducting business or just plain gossiping on the phone when disaster struck.
At the very least, it’s a daring first step, and we should be proud of being in a state that has become one of the first to show the way.
The Reeves Law Group is a law firm with offices throughout California dedicated exclusively to the representation of personal injury victims, including victims of car accidents. Please visit our website at trlglaw.com. If you desire a free consultation on a personal injury matter, please call us at (800) 644-8000 or email us.